Link to original video by Excess Returns

A Valuation MasterClass | Michael Mauboussin

Summary of "Valuation MasterClass | Michael Mauboussin"

Short Summary:

This podcast episode features a conversation with Michael Mauboussin, a renowned investor and author, about his approach to valuation and investing. He emphasizes the importance of understanding the underlying economics of a business rather than relying solely on traditional valuation metrics. Mauboussin advocates for a "consilience" approach, integrating various disciplines to gain a deeper understanding of markets and companies. He introduces "Expectations Investing," a three-step process that involves reverse engineering a company's value based on its current price, analyzing its ability to meet those expectations, and finally making an investment decision. The episode also touches on the impact of passive investing, the paradox of skill, and the importance of base rates in decision-making.

Detailed Summary:

Section 1: Introduction and Michael Mauboussin's Role

• The episode introduces Michael Mauboussin, Head of Consilient Research at Morgan Stanley Investment Management's Counterpoint Global.
• Mauboussin explains the concept of "consilience," which involves unifying knowledge from different disciplines to understand complex systems.
• He describes his role as focusing on internal investment process improvement, writing research for both internal and external audiences, and engaging in external activities like conferences and client interactions.

Section 2: Evolution of Security Analysis and Valuation

• Mauboussin discusses the evolution of security analysis and valuation since the days of Ben Graham.
• He highlights the integration of decision-making literature, including concepts like prospect theory, heuristics, and biases, into the teaching of security analysis.
• He emphasizes the importance of understanding and mitigating the impact of cognitive biases on investment decisions.
• He acknowledges the significant advancements in financial tools and techniques since Ben Graham's time, including the formalization of cost of capital and competitive strategy.

Section 3: Fundamentals and Market Behavior

• Mauboussin addresses the common narrative that fundamentals have become irrelevant in recent markets.
• He argues that while there are pockets of speculation, like meme stocks, markets have generally been acting sensibly.
• He believes that the pandemic and subsequent central bank actions have led to predictable shifts in valuation, favoring companies benefiting from digitization and low discount rates.
• He acknowledges the unusual market activity driven by retail investors and the "Board of Market Hypothesis," but emphasizes that such episodes are not new and tend to end poorly for speculators.
• He highlights the importance of distinguishing between investing (buying a stake in a business for long-term value growth) and speculating (hoping for a price increase).

Section 4: Expectations Investing and the Importance of Understanding Underlying Economics

• Mauboussin introduces his book "Expectations Investing" and its three-step process:
  • Step 1: Reverse engineer the company's value based on its current price, identifying the key drivers of value.
  • Step 2: Analyze the company's ability to meet, exceed, or fall short of those expectations, using historical, strategic, and financial analysis.
  • Step 3: Make an investment decision based on the analysis from steps 1 and 2.
• He emphasizes the importance of understanding the economic assumptions embedded in valuation multiples, arguing that they are not a shortcut but rather a shorthand for the valuation process.
• He cautions against assuming that growth is inherently valuable, stating that growth adds value only when a company earns above its cost of capital.

Section 5: Factor Investing and its Impact on Market Efficiency

• Mauboussin discusses the rise of factor-based quantitative investing strategies.
• He explains that factor investing identifies anomalies relative to the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM), which suggests that factors are either behavioral or reflect previously unidentified risks.
• He distinguishes between value investing (buying something for less than it's worth) and the value factor (buying statistically cheap stocks based on metrics like price-to-book or price-to-earnings).
• He believes that the jury is still out on the impact of factor investing on market efficiency, but acknowledges that it has not had a significant measurable effect.

Section 6: Intangible Assets and the Challenge of Valuation

• Mauboussin discusses the increasing importance of intangible assets in modern economies, which are not reflected on balance sheets and are typically expensed, impacting earnings.
• He argues that companies like Amazon and Google made significant intangible investments that were not fully captured by traditional valuation metrics.
• He emphasizes the need to understand the underlying economics of a business, focusing on cash flows rather than relying solely on accounting metrics.
• He suggests that capitalizing intangible assets and reflecting them in book value can improve the quality of valuation signals.

Section 7: The Paradox of Skill and the Role of Luck in Investing

• Mauboussin introduces the concept of the paradox of skill, which states that as the absolute level of skill in a field rises, the relative skill difference between the best and average participants decreases, leading to a greater role for luck in determining outcomes.
• He argues that the high level of skill and uniformity in the investment industry makes luck a significant factor in investment success.
• He suggests that while models can be helpful in certain aspects of investing, like position sizing and applying base rates, they are less effective in capturing the qualitative judgments and long-term strategic thinking required for successful investing.

Section 8: Base Rates and Decision-Making

• Mauboussin concludes by advocating for the use of base rates in investment decision-making.
• He explains that base rates represent the historical performance of a larger reference class, which can provide valuable context for understanding current situations and making more informed predictions.
• He emphasizes the importance of considering base rates alongside personal experience and information gathering, as they can help ground our thinking and provide a more realistic perspective on potential outcomes.

Notable Quotes:

• "Investing is buying a partial stake in a business with an understanding that you are you're going to get the benefits of that value growth over time. Speculating is buying something hoping that it'll go up."
• "The price-to-earnings multiple is not an analytical shortcut, it's an economic cul-de-sac."
• "Growth adds value when a company's earning above the cost of capital."
• "The skill is not only high but it's uniform."
• "The natural way to think about the world or solve your problems is to gather a bunch of information and combine it with your own inputs and experience and project into the future. That's what we all do left our own devices. Using base rates says, I'm going to think about what I'm facing now or my problem as an instance of a larger reference class. I'm going to basically ask what happened when other people or organizations were in this position before."